24 Mar 2008
Home Up 28 Jan 2008 24 Mar 2008

 

     

Up

 

Hit Counter

USAF MSC ASSOCIATION

BOARD OF DIRECTORS MINUTES

24 MAR 2008

OPENING

1. Chairman Art Small called the meeting to order at 9:00PM EST on 24 Mar 2008. Agenda is at Attachment 1.

  1. Attendees:

Art Small, Chairman

Ralph Charlip, President

Jim Moreland, Vice President

Ed Nugent, Chairman Emeritus

Charlie Brown, Secretary

Al Obuchowski, Treasurer

Bob Hauser, Director

Ray Inman, Director

Denise Lew, Director

Mac McClean, Director

Kevin OShea, 2009 Reunion Host

Wayne Terry, Director

Joe Vocks, Director

Absent:

Al Baskin, Director

Bill Copeland, Counsel

STANDING BUSINESS

3. MINUTES APPROVAL: The Board approved the minutes of the 24 Jan 08 meeting as published.

4. FINANCIAL REPORT: Tabled until June meeting.

 

OLD BUSINESS

5. 2009 REUNION: Kevin OShea gave an outstanding briefing to the Board on his progress. He compared a number of potential hotels. The range of topics included costs, location, weather, access, amenities, and capabilities. (See Attachments 2 and 3) Timing of the reunion is critical as October is the start of "high season." During October the nice weather brings on competing conventions, local college activities and the normal increase in tourists, all of which tend to drive up prices. Kevins top recommendation is the Francis Marion Hotel. He felt the location (middle of the Historical District), value for our money, support systems and capabilities all seem to fit nicely with what we want for our reunion. The Francis Marion is a historic hotel where the ambiance is truly fantastic. A blend of historical venues, shopping, and restaurants are all within easy walking distance. The Hospitality Suite is located on the 12th Floor and overlooks Charleston Harbor. The Hotels capacity and support structure is such that we will have no problems conducting business and leisure activities.

The scope of Kevins presentation enabled the Board, after a short discussion, to approve a motion that we proceed in obtaining the Francis Marion Hotel for the dates 11-14 September 2009. Kevin stated he would put a draft package together and coordinate with Mac McClean and Bill Copeland before signing any contract. Wayne Terry will add a short blurb for the April Newsletter as to dates. Since we have a good lead time, Denise was asked to check the Corps Chiefs schedule to see if it would be possible to schedule some active duty functions around the Reunion dates. Perhaps something could be arranged the week preceding the reunion and folks could stay over for that weekend or come early for the reunion followed by their meeting the following week. (OPEN: Kevin OShea, Denise Lew)

6. NEW MEMBER RECRUITING EFFORTS: The Board discussion centered on two questions. First, should the Association be recruiting active duty members? Second, how can our resources best be targeted and utilized to obtain better results?

After a lengthy discussion, the members agreed we need to have active duty participation to remain a vibrant entity especially as the Medical Service Corps gets smaller due to overall force reductions. Currently, presentations are made at HSA and a Team Builder Award is sponsored that gives free membership to the winner. Presentations are given at the annual ACHE meeting but time allotted is limited. This year we had a booth on Air Force Day and handed out brochures. But there has been limited response in terms of recruitment from either venue. This year only a few MSCs have joined from these efforts. The Board felt that young officers are undecided as to a career but need to be made aware of the Association.

Ray Inman suggested that we look at restructuring our efforts to focus on mid to senior level officers who are career minded. Ray cited numerous mid level, senior executive courses and seminars which we could apply our focus. These officers will probably be more inclined to be interested in joining because they are career and the more senior officers will be approaching retirement. Jim Moreland agreed that perhaps our efforts should be limited at HSA to an MSC Display Board, our Team Builder Award and its associated costs, and having the Instructors give the pitch handing out brochures, etc. Ray further suggested that we always hand out applications at all events where we are present, HSA, ACHE, etc. The Board agreed with this approach.

Art asked Denise if she could build a list of those activities, seminars or training courses which we could participate. Corps Chief approval will need to be obtained. (Open: Denise Lew)

Joe Volks recommended we send out congratulatory letters on promotions to 04 through 06 and upon retirement. Ralph Charlip and Denise Lew will coordinate how the mechanics of such a program will flow. (OPEN: Ralph Charlip, Denise Lew)

ADJOURNMENT AND NEXT MEETING

7. Chairman Art Small adjourned the meeting at 8:43PM EST, 24 March 2008. The next meeting will be late June.

Respectfully Submitted

CHARLES W BROWN, USAF, MSC, COL (Ret)

SECRETARY

 

Attachments

1. Agenda

2. 2009 Reunion Hotel Recommendations

3. 2009 Reunion Hotel Comparisons

USAF MSC Association Board Meeting Agenda

24 March 2008

DATE: 24 Mar 08

TIME: 9:00PM EST

 OPENING: Art Small

ROLL CALL: Charlie Brown

MINUTES APPROVAL: 28 Jan 08 Meeting

FINANCIAL STATUS REPORT: Al Obuchowski

2009 REUNION: Kevin OShea

SPECIAL TOPICS:

New Member Recruiting Issues

 

ADJOURNMENT

Next Meeting and Closing Comments Art Small

 

Attachment 1

2009 USAF MSC Association Reunion

Hotel Recommendations

bulletFactors affecting hotel selection
bulletDesired daily room rate for attendees
bulletTime of year October is high season in Charleston
bulletRoom rates jump
bulletCompeting events
bulletHotels unwilling to commit blocks of rooms
bulletConvention size
bulletLocation
bulletMost desirable is in/near Historic District (see arrow on peninsula in picture)
bulletApproach in selection
bulletSolicitation for information through Charleston Visitors and Convention Bureau
bulletLimited response
bulletFollowed with phone calls to additional hotels
bulletHotels considered
bulletFrancis Marion Hotel (recommended)
bulletIdeal location
bulletHistoric Hotel of America
bulletSufficient capacity
bulletUnaffordable room rates in October (>$200)
bulletTown and Country Inn
bulletAdvertises that it caters to military reunions
bullet Bad location
bulletHoliday Inn Historic District
bulletIdeal location
bulletInsufficient meeting room capacity
bulletUnwilling to hold block of rooms in October
bulletUnaffordable room rates in October
bulletCourtyard by Marriott/Marriott Hotel
bulletCourtyard has affordable room rates but insufficient meeting room capacity
bulletMarriott has sufficient meeting room capacity but unaffordable room rates
bullet mile distance between two hotels with available shuttle
bulletEmbassy Suites Airport/Convention Center (recommended)
bulletHoliday Inn Patriots Point (recommended)

 

2009 Reunion Hotel Recommendations

 

Hotel Locations

 

Francis Marion Hotel

Embassy Suites Airport/Convention Center

Holiday Inn Patriots Point

Availability

11 14 Sep

2 5 Oct

23 26 Oct

2009 Daily Room Rate

(4-Day Total)

$146

($657)

$139

All 2-room suites

Brkfst buffet/evening reception incl.

($625.50)

$109/Thursday and Sunday

$139/Friday and Saturday

($558)

     

25 28 Sep

 

23%

 

$99/Thursday and Sunday

$129/Friday and Saturday

($508.44)

Tax

Accommodations

12.5%

12.5%

11.5%

Food & Beverage

9.5%

Sales

7.5%

8.5%

Service Charge

20%

22%

20%

Complementary Rooms

1/50

1/25

Booking Considerations

Attrition clause: responsible for 90% of blocked rooms. Reservations must be made NLT 8/11/09 for group rate

Reservations must be made before 9/1/09 for group rate

Reservations must be made NLT 9/22/09 for group rate

Location

Ideal location at end of historic district walking distance to shops, restaurants and many sites

Very convenient to airport 5-minute drive

Convenient to high-interest sites

5-minute drive to historic district

0.5 mile to Patriots Point

1.5 miles to Shem Creek

Transportation To/From

Airport

None

Free

None

Historic District

N/A

$10/person round-trip

Parking

$12/Day

$17/Day Valet

(Charleston City Public Garage)

Shared with convention center 300 free spaces for hotel guests. Potential for $4 entrance fee otherwise

Free

No capacity issues

 

 

 

Francis Marion Hotel

Embassy Suites Airport/Convention Center

Holiday Inn Patriots Point

Meeting Room Capacity

Unlimited for association needs

130 (banquet) 150 (classroom)

Need 2-hour break between memorial service and banquet for meeting room breakdown

Hospitality Suite

Ideal hospitality suite set-up.

Can bring in outside liquor.

$100 initial set-up; $50 daily refresh

Designated hospitality suite on second floor does not provide needed capacity. Requires use of first-floor meeting room. Liquor license prohibits bringing in outside liquor to first-floor location.

No designated hospitality suite. Can use first-floor meeting room. No issues with bringing in outside liquor.

Sunday Alcohol Sales

No issues

Hotel will need to obtain Sunday liquor license. Will not charge association if >$4K food/beverage sales

Business Center

Very limited

Full

Very limited

Web Address

www.thefrancismarion.com

www.embassysuitescharleston.com

www.himtpleasant.com

2009 Reunion Hotel Comparisons

Home ] Up ]